Replacing a bathtub may seem like a straightforward task—but anyone who’s tackled a bathroom remodel knows it’s anything but. From selecting the right bathtub options to understanding the tub cost, there are several decisions to make before the first tile is even touched.
As a designer and contractor, I’ve walked countless homeowners through the bathtub replacement process. Here are the 10 most common questions I get—answered with the clarity and confidence you need to get it right the first time.
1. How do I know it’s time for a bathtub replacement?
The signs are usually obvious: cracks, stains, leaks, or simply an outdated look. But even if your tub is technically functional, a replacement can still be worthwhile if you’re planning a bathroom transformation. Whether it’s about style, function, or space optimization, a tub swap can be the upgrade your bathroom needs.
2. What types of bathtubs should I consider?
There’s a wide range of bathtub options, each with its own pros and cons:
Alcove tubs – great for tight spaces and shower-tub combos
Freestanding tubs – make a dramatic design statement
Soaking tubs – deeper for a spa-like experience
Built-in baths – customizable with tile surrounds or storage
The best choice depends on your bathroom upgrade goals, space, and lifestyle.
3. Can I replace the bathtub without redoing the whole bathroom?
Absolutely. A bathtub replacement can be a stand-alone project, especially if you’re happy with your existing tile and plumbing layout. That said, many homeowners use it as a springboard for a full bathroom makeover.
Just keep in mind: matching new fixtures and finishes with older ones can be tricky. Sometimes, a partial remodel creates more contrast than cohesion.
4. What’s involved in the removal of the old tub?
Old tub removal involves more than just ripping it out. A professional will:
Shut off water and disconnect plumbing
Protect floors and nearby fixtures
Remove tile or surround as needed
Haul away the old bath fixture
Hidden issues like rot or mold are sometimes uncovered, so budgeting a bit extra for surprises is smart.
5. How long does a bathtub replacement take?
A basic tub install can take anywhere from 1 to 3 days, depending on complexity and prep work. If plumbing needs to be moved or new tile installed, the renovation timeline extends. Always get a clear schedule from your contractor to minimize downtime.
6. What are the typical costs for bathtub replacement?
Tub cost varies widely based on materials, style, and labor. Here’s a general range:
Basic alcove tub + install: $1,000–$2,500
Mid-range soaking tub or freestanding unit: $2,500–$5,000
High-end luxury bath with custom tile and fixtures: $5,000–$10,000+
Get multiple quotes, and remember: the cheapest option today can lead to expensive fixes tomorrow.
7. Can I DIY a bathtub replacement?
Unless you’re experienced with plumbing, waterproofing, and finish work, I don’t recommend it. Installing a modern bathtub improperly can lead to leaks, water damage, or uneven surfaces.
Bathtub replacement is one project where hiring a pro pays off in peace of mind—and long-term performance.
8. What design considerations should I think about?
Look beyond just shape and size. Consider:
Bathroom layout – Does a freestanding tub crowd the space?
Materials – Acrylic is lightweight and affordable; cast iron is classic but heavy
Features – Heated backrests, air jets, or water-saving designs?
Style compatibility – Will your new tub complement the rest of your bathroom remodel?
A well-chosen tub should be both functional and harmonious with your overall bathroom upgrade.
Don’t wait!
Contact us now! Transform Your Space, Elevate Your Home – Let First Bathroom Remodel Bring Your Dream Bathroom to Life
9. What mistakes should I avoid?
Here are the most common missteps:
Choosing a tub that’s too large or small for the space
Skimping on materials or waterproofing
Ignoring plumbing limitations
Forgetting accessibility or resale considerations
Avoid these, and your tub remodel will enhance both comfort and home value.
10. Is a bathtub replacement really worth it?
In short—yes. Whether you’re upgrading to a soaking tub, replacing an outdated shower-tub combo, or creating a spa-like retreat, a bathtub replacement can dramatically improve both your daily routine and the long-term appeal of your home.
Done right, it’s not just a renovation. It’s a transformation.
📣 Call to Action:
Thinking about replacing your bathtub? Let our team help you choose the right design, layout, and features for your space. Get a quote today and start your bathroom transformation with confidence.